Gender (studies) trouble in Hungary
Gender studies challenge existing structures that are perceived as natural and enduring, and in doing so, they directly challenge the ideological commitments of the radical right.
Hungarian citizens protest in Brussels on 15.04.2018 against re-election of Viktor Orban. Wiktor Dabkowski/Press Association. All rights reserved.
In August, an announcement was made by the Hungarian Prime Ministerâs office that gender studies courses, as of September 2019, would not be funded or recognised by the government. Students presently enrolled will be given the chance to finish their degrees, but no more will be admitted.
At present, two universities offer gender studies degrees â" EÃ¶tvÃ¶s LorÃ¡nd University (ELTE), a publicly funded university, and Central European University, which is private. The ban was announced without meaningful consultation with those impacted, and the universities offering the program were given twenty-four hours to respond, a timeframe in the middle of the summer holidays. The proposed ban attempts to dismiss and discredit gender studies as a field of inquiry not economically worthwhile. Itâs also been said that the gender studies programs are antithetical to the governmentâs own ideological position on gender as fixed.
The international response to the ban has been critical of the governmentâs stance and included rapid expressions of solidary with scholars in Hungary. The European International Studies Association (EISA) recently released a statement that, in keeping with what many other academic institutions and associations have similarly stated, expresses criticism of the decision, the lack of prior engagement with the universities impacted by the dec ision, and expresses solidarity with gender studies scholars in Hungary.
The EISA is also holding a roundtable discussion on academic freedom in western and eastern Europe at their annual conference next week, and in their statement specifically highlight the importance of academic freedom, and the ability of universities to set their own curricula, as âfundamental to the functioning of democracy.â
The political situation in Hungary, under Prime Minister Viktor OrbÃ¡n, has been previously discussed here on multiple occasions, and elsewhere. OrbÃ¡nâs vision of governance in Hungary is one of what he calls illiberal democracy, and it appears bent towards a conservative social position and a particular form of nationalism that ties one to the other. Freedom House included a discussion of OrbÃ¡n and his concept of illiberal democracy in their report on modern authoritarianism, specifically referencing the crackdown on civil society. They also highlight the fear t hat illiberalism is notably intolerant of minority groups, and takes particular note of LGBTQ+ people. It is therefore not entirely surprising that OrbÃ¡nâs government would move to ban gender studies in the country, but it is shocking and disturbing.
The attempt to curtail academic freedom through the proposed ban is certainly one worrying element. Universities are, ideally, a source of challenge to and critique of power: the freedom to discuss, research, and teach is an integral part of this. That it is specifically gender studies that is under attack by what has been called here the radical right political parties of Hungary is additionally illuminating. Gender studies broadly, and feminist interventions into other disciplines such as feminist international relations, at their core inspire and demand critical thinking about and critical engagement with the world. Gender studies challenge existing structures that are perceived as natural and enduring, and in doing so, t hey directly challenge the ideological commitments of the radical right.
The idea of gender as an ideology has been around since the 1990s in conservative and radical right discourses that look to dismiss gender-based social and scientific inquiry as itself an ideological position, but has resurfaced dramatically in right-wing and populist movements. Gender studies, or indeed engaging critically with gender more broadly, has been at odds with radical right agendas outside Hungary for decades. I have previously written about the foundational role of nostalgia in radical right movements and the attendant reliance on a sense of traditional gender roles involved. Engaging with ideas and understandings of gender necessarily threatens these positions, and by and large radical right movements are anti-feminist. Furthermore, banning gender studies alienates pupils and individuals who do not conform to notions of gender norms and gender expressions of these radical right ideologies.
My own work is in feminist and queer international relations and feminist security studies, and my favourite way to introduce the topics to students is to highlight the ways that feminist inquiry, as in critical theory more broadly, asks us to look to the margins â" to ask: who or what is being excluded here? What assumptions are being taken for granted? Gender studies, for all its rich interdisciplinarity, is critical. Students who undertake a gender studies course are trained to think critically, and to engage critically with the world around them. It is therefore disturbing, and shocking, but not entirely surprising, that a radical right group, movement, or party would attempt to eradicate it.About the author
M egan Armstrong is a Teaching Fellow at the University of Birmingham. She is a specialist on identity politics and radicalisation; gender and white supremacist movements; as well as migration and nationalism.Related Articles Hungary and the end of democracy
Samuel SalzbornLiberals against nationalism in Central Europe? It would have been a nice idea
SeÃ¡n HanleyJames DawsonHungaryâs regime is proof that capitalism can be deeply authoritarian
Gabor Scheiring Read On
Visit the Centre for Analysis of the Radical Right (#CARR)Subjects
International politicsSource: Google News Hungary | Netizen 24 Hungary